u.s. supreme court building
Column
April 10, 2017

Neil Gorsuch’s Dysfunctional Nuclear Family

It Is Disappointing That the GOP Could Not Search for a Judge Who Is Representative of the Average American

Four hundred nineteen. The number of days that the United States Supreme Court was missing a justice due to congress’s refusal to give Merrick Garland a congressional hearing. On Friday, after a year of undermining and insulting the executive power of President Obama, republicans in congress struggled to get their controversial nominee confirmed in light of a liberal filibuster.

They won, but only after completely changing the rules. The GOP employed a “nuclear option” by reducing the number of votes needed to overcome a filibuster to 50, thus rendering the filibuster completely useless against Supreme Court nominees. In doing so, they dramatically changed the nature of the senate confirmation process by eliminating the element of debate. They undermined the check and balances that were employed against every previous Supreme Court nominee. And, they set a precedent for silencing dissenting senators rather than accommodating them.

Eliminating the filibuster on Supreme Court nominations sends the nation down a slippery slope. Supreme Court justices, unlike cabinet members, are appointed for life, and far outlast a presidency. Thanks to the new rule change, the party in power can make drastic and irreversible changes to the judicial branch, while the minority party is left with little capacity for intervention.

But it isn’t just the precedent that’s scary here; it’s Neil Gorsuch himself. He may become the most conservative justice on the supreme court, at a time when many are desperately relying on the courts to foster social progress. Needless to say, Gorsuch’s confirmation will hit some groups harder than others.

Gorsuch has a history of ruling to undermine women’s access to preventative health care, contraception and other services provided through Planned Parenthood, and he has defended the right of health care companies to deny women birth control coverage. Now more than ever, with a president and congress determined to undermine Planned Parenthood and the right to healthcare, millions of women are depending on the supreme court to protect their rights. They cannot count on Gorsuch to take their side.

Gorsuch is also unlikely to be an ally for the LGBT community. While a majority of the country supports the existing judicial precedent protecting marriage equality, Gorsuch has insinuated that the issue is still up for debate. This puts many LGBT couples at risk of losing privileges that others enjoy when it comes to health care, social security or even parental rights. He also ruled to deny hormone therapy to an imprisoned transgender woman in 2015, demonstrating that he cannot be trusted to protect even some of the most basic rights of the queer community.

Gorsuch’s views fall far behind the rest of the country. But what is most unsettling is that he secured his critical position in a completely unprecedented manner, skipping over the obstacles that every nominee before him has been required to overcome. After making a joke out of the President Obama’s qualified nominee, it is disappointing that the GOP could not recognize the concerns of the other side and search for a judge who is representative of the average American, instead of cheating their way to the finish line.

# # #

Grace Hauser is a freshman at the University of Wisconsin Madison studying political science and economics and an intern at One Wisconsin Now.

michael screnock smiling at the nra
Press Release

Did Michael Screnock Promise the NRA He Supports More Guns in Schools?

Supreme Court candidate Michael Screnock has still not disclosed what he wrote to the NRA in a letter the gun lobby required to earn their endorsement.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/23/2018
madison wisconsin capitol skyline
Press Release

GOP Assembly Majority Already Set to Call It a Year

Same GOP Legislators Who Attacked Public Assistance Beneficiaries Will Collect Their Own Government Pay and Benefits for 312 More Days.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/22/2018
gavel
In the News

Analiese Eicher: Red flags should sink judicial nomination of Michael Brennan

The U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee set aside common decency and longstanding traditions when it voted to approve Donald Trump’s nomination of Michael Brennan.
Capital Times
02/21/2018
voters voting
Press Release

Election Night Losers: Scott Walker, NRA, WMC and Michael Screnock

Despite a massive spending advantage and no other conservative opposition, the hand-picked candidate of Gov. Scott Walker failed to snag a majority of the vote.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/21/2018
white silhouette of scales of justice overlaying supreme court bench
Press Release

Supreme Court Primary Another Loss for Right-Wing Political Machine

Wisconsin’s right-wing political machine went all in to buy a court seat for Michael Screnock but the voters of Wisconsin said, ‘not so fast.’
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/20/2018
wooden school desk with apple
Press Release

Republican Bill Would Put Guns in Wisconsin Schools

Wisconsin Republicans are introducing a second bill aimed at putting guns into K-12 schools in the state, the latest version aimed at private schools.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/19/2018
question mark
Press Release

What Did Michael Screnock Promise the NRA?

We deserve to know today what promises state Supreme Court candidate Michael Screnock made to the NRA to get the gun lobby’s endorsement.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/19/2018
jeremy thiesfeldt gun tweet
Press Release

Republican Shares Article Romanticizing Guns in Schools

Rep. Jeremy Thiesfeldt took to social media to share an article from a right-wing website romanticizing the presence of guns in schools years ago.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
02/16/2018