white silhouette of scales of justice overlaying supreme court bench
Press Release
April 5, 2017
Media Contact
Mike Browne, Deputy Director
(608) 444-3483
One Wisconsin Now

Will State High Court Clean Up Its Act and Reform Rules on Judicial Recusal?

Wisconsin Supreme Court Set to Consider Effort to Keep Judges From Deciding Cases Involving Big Campaign Contributors

MADISON, Wis. — To protect the integrity of our courts and maintain public trust in the justice system, judges ought not decide cases involving large campaign contributors. But the current rules governing the Wisconsin state courts and the conduct of judges fall short in preventing the appearance of, or actual, corruption. That’s why One Wisconsin Now has submitted a letter to the Wisconsin Supreme Court in support of an effort initiated by 54 retired Wisconsin judges to change the court’s judicial recusal rules, joining other state and national judicial watchdog groups in supporting the petition.

“Even the appearance of corruption is corrosive and undermines public trust that our courts will act in a fair and impartial manner,” said One Wisconsin Now Research Director Jenni Dye. “That’s why it’s so important for our state courts to have clear, strong rules requiring judges to recuse themselves in cases involving campaign contributors.”

At issue are rules originating from a 2010 proposal from the Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce and the Wisconsin Realtors Association to the Wisconsin Supreme Court to guide judges in deciding when they ought to recuse themselves from cases before them because of conflicts of interest – and when they did not need to do so. The conservative court majority subsequently adopted the rules, literally written by the special interests that spent big money to get them elected, allowing them to participate in cases involving parties that helped their campaigns.

Utilizing a court petition process, 54 retired judges from across the state and the political spectrum have called on the Wisconsin Supreme Court to reconsider the rules on judicial recusal. Their request is for “… an objective standard requiring recusal or disqualification of a judge when he or she has received the benefit of campaign contributions or assistance from a party or a lawyer …”

The judges advocating for reform note how important it is for our courts to be free from corruption, or even the appearance of corruption. Setting objective rules on recusals in cases involving groups or people that spent significant sums to help elect judges sends an important message to Wisconsin regarding our justice system.

Dye noted that the recusal rule reform petition is scheduled to be considered by the state high court during an open judicial conference on April 20.

She concluded, “It’s time for the court to take real action to clean up their image. Their choice is a simple one: accept the petition and begin to restore faith that our courts can be counted on to treat everyone equally under the law and act as a check on overreaches by the legislative and executive branches. Or reject the petition and defend a status quo where members of this Court and other judges can reap electoral rewards of massive special interest spending with no concern for the appearance, if not the existence, of actual corruption.”

# # #

One Wisconsin Now is a statewide communications network specializing in effective earned media and online organizing to advance progressive leadership and values.

wisconsin attorney general brad schimel
Press Release

A dangerous repeat drunken driver was still on the road at least in part because of the turnaround time at the state crime lab.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
10/16/2017
paul ryan
Press Release

Paul Ryan today is genuflecting before the state’s big business lobby about the Trump-Ryan plan to hand out tax breaks to the super rich.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
10/16/2017
scot ross roast toast
Press Release

There’s no better way to celebrate Scot Ross than to invite his friends to share out loud what we’ve been muttering under our breaths for a decade.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
10/13/2017
university of wisconsin bascom hall
Press Release

Right-wing politicians and academics are using tax dollars and chasing more money from right-wing foundations to promote their ideological agenda.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
10/12/2017
graduates overhead
Press Release

One Wisconsin Now and Student Loan Debt Crisis are urging national Democrats to include critical student loan reforms as part of their “Better Deal” agenda.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
10/11/2017
scot ross on unspun
In the News

We are unspinning the political headlines with our analysts, Scot Ross, Executive Director of One Wisconsin Now... and Bill McCoshen... Managing Partner of Capitol Consultants.
WMTV-TV
10/11/2017
wisconn valley shirt
Press Release

Wisconsin taxpayers are on the hook for billions of dollars as part of the largest state subsidy for a foreign corporation in history.
One Wisconsin Logo
One Wisconsin Now
10/09/2017
am joy, msnbc 2017-10-08
In the News

Supreme Court gerrymandering case focusing on Wisconsin raises the issue of defending voting rights against voter suppression. Joy Reid and her panel discuss.
MSNBC
10/08/2017